[cavisne]

It seems the email part is optional (ie you can choose to share your verified email with the company if you want).

The above scenario goes against what they are trying to achieve though

1) If you support SSO and email/password - then the email and password are still stored (and possibly not hashed and salted if the developer is incompetent) - so you are at risk of compromise if you reuse passwords 2) If you store the users actual email, you are putting them at risk of credential stuffing, as well as opening them up to tracking

The EU can always surprise, but I suspect they would actually like this because it addresses key risks to consumers of password reuse, credential stuffing, and tracking. Additionally it competes against their ideological targets, Facebook and Google.

[danielscrubs]

EU is not picking on FB and Google specifically. This mindset is toxic. They are picking on all monopolies for European customers and have been for a long time. Basically we believe the market is not healthy if there isn’t any competition.

[jkirsteins]

This is a bit rose tinted outlook. GDPR does not increase competition, the amount of regulation in EU and worker protections in place raise barriers for new competitors. France has laws that prohibit new movies from being put on Netflix in order to support local distributors etc.

Not saying what the EU does is goos or bad, but painting it as pro free market competition seems unfounded.

[addicted]

GDPR isn’t about addressing monopolies. It’s about addressing privacy and data ownership.

Every tech related legislation doesn’t and shouldn’t need to so,be every tech related problem. The EU has other, non GDPR related, mechanisms to handle monopoly issues.

[jkirsteins]

My point is EU will adopt regulation that actively harms competition (such as GDPR), because they have different priorities (e.g. privacy, data ownership as you mentioned).

So to me it seems unfounded to say EU cares about market health and is not, in fact, just picking on FB and Google.

I am honestly curious what you think are examples of EU mechanisms fostering healthy markets. Maybe the MS case but that is the same “EU picks on US tech giant” genre.

[danielscrubs]

Like breaking up the Samsung-Philips cartel?

I’m not sure what kind of examples you want.