Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by c256 2571 days ago
I can’t think of any applications written using those (or any other, actually) cross-platform toolkits for Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, and Android that were even moderately successful in the market. Generally, cross-platform UIs are disliked or hated everywhere; sometimes with the exception that they’re considered decent in their one truly native environment and terrible elsewhere. Qt definitely falls into this group.

Can you suggest a couple examples? I’m no fan of Electron, but I don’t see it as being so easily replaced as you seem to be suggesting.
3 comments
giovannibajo1 2571 days ago
You’re thinking of a timeframe in which apps embraced native style of operating systems. Slack does not do that, it’s a web app with a custom UI that doesn’t feel native on any OS. Thus, it would be perfectly sensible to rewrite it once in QML with a single codebase.

If anything, the main objection should be difficulty of hiring QML developers compared to JavaScript/CSS.

link
ubercow13 2571 days ago
Doesn't the success of Slack counter your whole point? It is built using a cross-platform toolkit for Windows, macOS and Linux, and is to some degree disliked or hated everywhere for the same reasons that Qt might be.
link
BubRoss 2571 days ago
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qt_(software)#Applications_u...

Some notable programs:

Adobe Photoshop Album, Adobe Photoshop Elements, AMD's driver tool, CryEngine, Autodesk Maya, Google Earth, Mathematica, Opera, OBS, Skype, Teamviewer, Telegram, VLC media player, Wireshark, QtCreator, Qbittorrent, Nuke, Xnview

link