Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by barry-cotter 2581 days ago
Improvements in teaching are very unlikely to change the rank ordering of who learns fastest/most/best. It can absolutely change how much I’d learned and when individual students learn something. Online teaching is far more conducive to mastery learning and ability grouping than offline education. Look at Lambda School for an example. If you have large cohorts starting on a regular basis you can have some people progressing slower than others but ensure they get there eventually in a way that’s not going to happen in a normal classroom environment. The scope for individualised instruction in an environment where you have classes of 15-30 students is limited. If you have 200 students starting every four weeks you can divide them into ten 20 person classes based on where they are in the curriculum and they’ll do much better than if they were doing things they’d already mastered or for which they just don’t have the prerequisites.

On a more purely technological basis integrating spaced repetition into instructional design would be a massive win. Imagine if people actually remembered what they’d been taught in school instead of having a hazy idea the US Civil War was somewhere in the 1800s.

1 comments

Lamda school picks winners from the outset. Public education doesn't get that option.
So? With one on one to one on three tuition you can get the average child to the 95th percentile for their age group. That’s the Bloom Two Sigma effect[1]. Tutoring is extremely effective when it comes to teaching but it’s not cost effective. With classes finely graded enough by ability and prior knowledge you can get reasonably close to that with much larger numbers of students, or you can just call it Mastery learning[2]. That’s possible without picking winners. It’s not possible in public schools for institutional and historical reasons but we’re talking about education, not public schools.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloom%27s_2_sigma_problem

[2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mastery_learning