Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by glenneroo 2573 days ago
OK then why not put a couple extra AoA sensors in? I thought everything critical on airliners was supposedly redundant?
2 comments

Indeed, part of this story is that the MCAS system was not classified as "critial" (i.e., a system which can cause a crash if it fails). If it had been, then it would have faced additional scrutiny and they'd probably needed three AoA sensors and majority voting. Apparently the authority of the MCAS system was increased during development, with the criticality judgement based on the old smaller value.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/faa-saw-737-max-flight-control-...

From what I've read the Max has 2 AoA sensors, but reads from only 1 at a time, and MCAS chooses that 1 sensor randomly.