Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Gallactide 2587 days ago
It's amazing that all US critical posts are being downvote-bombed...

Also the claim that the US is not lax in its regulation is a bad joke. Half of the parties available literally made de-regulation their damn group mantra...

7 comments

Please don't break the site guidelines by going on about downvoting, and especially please don't post nationalistic flamebait here.

HN users have a variety of views on both sides of any divisive topic.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

You can't down-vote posts on HN--only comments?
Posts use "flags", which downweight the posts much like downvoting comments does.
I'm American myself, don't mean to bag on a country, just was surprised by a few comments.

Fair enough though, didn't mean to come across as polemic/whining hahaha.

I'll try to conform to HN netiquette.

Imagine the reaction if that same piece had being published by RT.
This is hacker news, not Reddit world news or politics...
I'm not sure what that means, but not all hackers are in the US.
Not gp but I think the original post’s tone sounds like a political post on reddit, and I agree it doesn’t belong here. It’s classic complaining about downvoting.

All that aside, I think this is an interesting article we can talk about without this. To me it sounds like it might be a symptom of regulatory capture in the US.

And only about 50% of Hacker News users are in the US.
HN is traditionally quite pro-US to the point that many here were defending Boeing during the 737 Max fiasco. Not to mentions the vitriol against the EU when it fined American tech giants.
I find it amusing or at least ironic that you say "many here were defending Boeing during the 737 Max fiasco" when in reality the mainstream opinion here is very anti-Boeing and there is a down-voted and dead comment that says they didn't see anyone defending Boeing. Well of course, those people are/were a tiny minority so they got down-voted and buried like that comment. It's a perfect illustration of what it's asking about.

And this is going to get down-voted because of the first of fight club.

There are a lot of users on both sides of the topic, just like there on other controversial topics. But it always feels like the "mainstream" opinion is being the one most opposed to your own. The confident generalizations people make about HN are nearly all based on this feeling. That's why they contradict one another.

https://hn.algolia.com/?query=%22hostile%20media%20effect%22...

I'm "anti-Boeing" here though and even I don't see much controversy. Everyone who isn't down-voted seems to think Boeing is solidly at fault to varying extents. There's no hostile media effect going on (from my POV on this issue).
There have been plenty of comments defending Boeing and not being downvoted, though probably not as many as are critical. That's a function of it being an indignation story, though. Indignation always wins.
To be honest, it's kind of a shit article?