Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by noisem4ker 2587 days ago
That was also the case with CRT displays. If a pixel is to stay black, no electron must be emitted to light up its phosphor.

This Google search frontend has been around long enough to claim it helped save considerable amount of energy on that principle:

http://www.blackle.com/about/

What they report about LEDs and CCFL isn't entirely correct, however. It may become in the future.

Technicalities aside, what once could be regarded as an environmental measure, today is a much more practical battery saving strategy.

3 comments

CRTs consume so much power that the beam current is negligible. The comparison is with backlit LCD screens, which have to have the backlight on regardless of how many black pixels you have.
Actually traditional tft displays need to apply a current to turn a pixel black, so if you don't use adaptive brightness that would dim the backlight if the display is mostly black, you actually consume more power with a black theme. I have a low power Pentium notebook with 15" led backlit screen and the difference between a terminal with black or white background is significant.
> I have a low power Pentium notebook with 15" led backlit screen and the difference between a terminal with black or white background is significant.

How significant? Turn the screen black, and show the remaining battery time estimate. Turn it white, do the same. I'm curious.

Battery at 74%. Sitting at black screen for about a minute, the highest estimate I got was 4:50, lowest 4:05. It was mostly showing numbers close to either of these, almost never something in between.

Switching to white I got 5:40 and 4:50 showing pretty much the same behavior.

It's an HP pavilion 15-p005ng with a Pentium N3530. Terrible machine btw. Linux freezes in irregular intervals, almost immediately with OpenGL stuff...

Surely it isn't extrapolating from current instantaneous power consumption?
I'm pretty sure that's how it works. The drivers report total battery capacity, current battery capacity, and current power draw, so the meters just do the math.
Not the case for LCDs with variable brightness backlight regions.
I remember my high school electrical engineering teacher challenging me to make a project out of comparing ways to save power with CRTs and LCDs. All black vs. all white screen had no measurable difference on my multimeter. I couldn't answer it at the time. I was convinced that it should save power.