Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by synaesthesisx 2591 days ago
The pioneers of the modern residency system were fueled by copious amounts of cocaine & other stimulants. Perhaps we need to reevaluate the requirements & expectations we place on medical residents today. It's essentially a form of professional hazing, and I personally know many surgical residents that are literally operating on people today while absurdly sleep deprived (by no fault of their own, just the insane hours of their program).

That said, if whoever's operating on me is running on 3 hours of sleep I'd rather they be hopped up on stimulants than not...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Stewart_Halsted

1 comments

One time I met with the head of an union and he told me many tough jobs (mining mainly) were perfomed while on drugs, which aren't available anymore causing all kinds of issues for the workers. I wonder if there was truth in that statement and maybe some formal research on this.
As I recall, the CIA did do a fair amount of this research on this, up to and including implanted cortical stimulators, which created some serious backlash.

Getting prescribed "on/off" switches in pill form is a well-known thing in the military. You just can't do combat air patrol over remote areas of Asia without some uppers. This quickly went from the pilots (mid-grade officers) and other fight crew, to being adopted by folks who have to go halfway around the world routinely (flag officers).

It's an active topic of conversation, some do, some don't. As a military physician who was a line officer and has been through 5 years of graduate medical education (internship + residency), and now occasionally has to do those round-the-world trips, it's not clear to me that there's an obvious right answer in policy or per-person. We (leaders and followers alike) expect leaders to function at the outer limits of human capacity, and have for a long time. I can tell you this: it doesn't get easier with age: a fairly common definition of success as a leader is proving your ability to take on more responsibility, so the more you do, the harder it gets. So avoid starting early.