Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Declanomous 2584 days ago
Based on the views you have espoused here, I would not call you a leftist commie. It sounds like freedom of speech is your number 1 concern, which would be in character for someone with views that could be considered alt-right. Maybe you are a libertarian, which could otherwise be referred to as an anarch-capatalist, but libertarianism is in no way a leftist movement.

While South Park and Eminem both 'triggered' a lot of people because of their use of obscenity, neither is leftist in any way, shape or form. South Park regularly attacks anyone who tries to change society, which is in no way a leftist mindset. As for Eminem, I can't think of a single example of left-leaning thought in any of them outside of freedom of speech.

In general I think you'd have a very hard time making the claim that the overton window is sliding to the left. Maybe the overton window is moving to the left for gender identity and sexual expression, but that is about it. The right has succeeded in moving the overton window substantially in their favor in most social and economic programs.

1 comments

His point is that it used to be that leftists defended freedom of speech from conservative oppression. Now it's the other way around.
Leftists aren't actually oppressing anybody. We're still under the rule of the far-right in the US (a country which does not actually have a left wing by Western standards). Voting with your dollar and pointing out bigotry and inequality is not oppression.
Leftists aren't, but Democratic Party partisans are. The difference is confusing to Americans.
> Leftists aren't actually oppressing anybody.

Well, that's certainly not true. They are absolutely oppressing people. They may be oppressing people that you or even I think ought be oppressed, but that doesn't mean they're not doing it.

> We're still under the rule of the far-right in the US (a country which does not actually have a left wing by Western standards).

That's true around economic issues. It's not so true around identity politics. The political climate around those issues in the US is very much left of center.

> Voting with your dollar and pointing out bigotry and inequality is not oppression.

That kind of depends on what exactly you mean by that. Naming and shaming individuals for social transgressions based on hearsay seems pretty oppressive to me.