Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by wc- 2590 days ago
Just a heads up, CoinMarketCap has been deliberately dragging its feet on addressing the issue of blatant wash trading to increase volume reported on some unregulated exchanges (especially some coming out of/focused on asian markets).

There are a number of sites working on more reliable volume metrics, one is here: https://messari.io/onchainfx . (edit: it is the "Real 10" 24 Hour Vol column)

What CMC is doing is disingenuous at best, they have a clear conflict of interest, and they are holding back the industry. We should push for alternative sources of information.
2 comments
bdcravens 2590 days ago
Yes, but why isn't every coin trading at 10x its market cap? Many of the same markets that report Tether volume also trade Bitcoin. If you look at relative differences between coins, even if volume isn't accurate, it indicates a very concerted effort to keep Tether propped up.
link
wc- 2590 days ago
The wash trading volume has nothing to do with tether (the trades are not even executing against the book in many cases, just reported as trades on the data feeds CMC consumes). Exchanges are using bots to wash trade back and forth on every trading pair to give the appearance of massive volume in an attempt to gain customers. It is very easy to see on charts and has nothing to do with propping tether up, whatever that means.

CoinMarketCap has been asked to exclude these exchanges from their volume reports for a long time and ignores them, most likely due to a conflict of interest (exchanges pay to advertise on CMC for example). Just like someone can create a new token and artificially inflate its market cap, exchanges can be created and artificially report their volume. CMC does nothing to filter this out and it results in a totally misleading view of the crypto markets.

OnChainFX is one example of an attempt to remove those wash-trading exchanges from the total volume reports.

My only reason for the inital reply was to urge people to not use CMC volume reports, there are better options out there that reflect real trading activity.

link
Canada 2590 days ago
Yeah CMC sucks. I've been looking at this one more lately: https://www.bti.live/currencies/
link