Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by adrianmonk 2598 days ago
Here's how I keep this straight mentally.

The rule is, in English, you can make a noun possessive by adding "'s" to the end.

Let me emphasize one part: that's the rule to make A NOUN possessive. "It" is a pronoun, not a noun! The rule doesn't apply any more than it applies to a verb or an adjective.

Hence you don't have stuff like "you's", "he's", "she's", "we's", or "I's", and you also don't have "it's".

1 comments

Pretty sure we do actually have he's and she's. "He's being an idiot", or "she's wrong about that."
Those are contractions, not possessives. "He is" and "she is", just like "it's" is always a contraction, never a possessive.
You're just proving the point: "'s" is only possessive for a noun. Your examples aren't possessives.
Yes, I misunderstood his point entirely. On reading my response again I also realize that my examples come off as a not so subtle insult, and which is not what I meant.
Those are not possessives. They're contractions, like it's.
Yes, but as a contraction of "he is", not as a possessive.