Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by crispinb 2605 days ago
Looks nice. I've been a 1password user for some years, but the lack of a proper linux client is a pest. Bitwarden seems like it would be worth a try.
2 comments

I too tried to like Bitwarden but have been disappointed. In the meantime I've made a basic linux CLI for read-only access, seems to be sufficient for the time being: https://github.com/vinc3m1/1pa
Nice! I don't have an opvault file right now as I use AgileBits' sync service, but I'll create one next time I'm in windows and give this a try.

(An aside: every time someone points out a golang repo I'm impressed by the code readability, given I'm only passingly familiar with the language)

Hmm. Not a great start - 'select all' on the linux client selects all the page text, rather than the items, so there's no way to bulk edit. Doesn't engender much confidence.

[Edit: OK it turns out to be an electron app, and a barely functional one at that]

Out of curiosity, why would you ever want to select all in your password manager?
In this particular case it's because I wanted to move all the items from a single imported 1Password vault (I have a few for different purposes) into a Bitwarden folder.

But more generally, when trying new software I tend to exercise its functionality as a first QA pass. There's a 'select all' entry in the Edit menu, and a keyboard shortcut, so it seems reasonable to try it. The failure isn't in itself a show stopper, but it's a mark against the app for me.

Folder organization makes sense. My guess is this shows up as a shortcut “for free” as a result of it being electron based. I think the “native” client is the newest client Bitwarden offers and probably hasn’t gotten as much polish yet.
Yes agree on the shortcut 'for free' aspect, but I'd consider expunging unused default menu items as part of a very basic pre-release checklist, rather than 'polish'. I don't share the frequently-expressed antipathy to electron apps, but many are quite shoddy, which only adds to their poor reputation. I've seen commercial apps which (for example) replace their whole window contents with a dragged image.

I'll keep an eye on Bitwarden - I like the overall shape of the project, but it's not ready for me yet (had some problems with the firefox extension also).