Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Buttons840 2608 days ago
They do have to publish prices, right? See: https://www.google.com/search?q=doctors+and+hospitals+must+p...

Maybe these aren't the "true prices"? I certainly wouldn't know where to look to find how much a "knee surgery" would cost, and I'd probably need to know some obscure medical code I don't have access to, as well as the intricacies of the knee surgery to know exactly what price to look up. I don't know how publishing "true prices" would work.

What kind of knee surgery am I having? Will I have to pay extra for the anesthesiologist? What kind of anesthesia will they be using? What about surgery preparation? What costs do I need to include for that? What about post surgery? There's probably a dozen cost items to add to the total for post surgery. The nurse brought me a glass of water. I'm not sure if that comes with a charge or not? Presumably someone has to pay for the plastic cup. Etc.
2 comments
dsfyu404ed 2608 days ago
>Maybe these aren't the "true prices"? I certainly wouldn't know where to look to find how much a "knee surgery" would cost, and I'd probably need to know some obscure medical code I don't have access to, as well as the intricacies of the knee surgery to know exactly what price to look up. I don't know how publishing "true prices" would work.

This is exactly the problem. They publish "prices" but those prices don't mean anything.

link
snowwrestler 2608 days ago
Published medical prices are not real because most procedures are paid by collective programs like private insurance or Medicare, which use their bargaining power to pay less--sometimes MUCH less--than the public "list price".

You're right that the complexity of medical billing also makes it difficult to anticipate and compare prices. However, that might be more of a side effect of how the billing is done, rather than an unavoidable attribute of medical care.

Arguably, medical providers have the information and capability to package procedures and publish what it actually costs to do them. But they have no incentive to do so, and many incentives to not do so.

link