Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by anon1m0us 2610 days ago
This is sick. I can't believe as human beings we still do this to other conscious creatures with feelings. It's emotionally traumatizing.

It's wrong.

4 comments

I'm not sure you are interpreting this correctly - its not like they were torturing the monkey.

This is almost the same as studies where they show humans a set of images and ask them which they like the most. Except in this case, they just show them the images and try to measure it.

Most of these comments are blowing this out of proportion.

Subjecting a being to a machine which automatically evolves stimuli to maximise fear response is not torture?
It's not maximizing "fear response", I'm not sure where everyone in this thread is getting that from. It's maximizing the response of particular visual cortex neurons, in structures where they're shown to be recognizers of specific shapes or concepts.

I.e. it's evolving images that this neuron thinks look most like a monkey, or a person. It's not the only neuron making that judgment, and it's all super nonlinear, so ofc it looks strange and distorted.

It's literally just doing this but with a real neuron instead of a virtual one: http://yosinski.com/deepvis

Things are relative here - you know they test experimental pharmaceutical drugs on monkeys too right?
You should see what is done to animals other than monkeys!
Maybe we should just test things on people instead?
Yes, if the human chooses to be the subject of the test, then yes. Monkeys don't give consent.
Neither do cows, pigs, or chickens. Should I feel sorry for them as well?
Yes.
Not to do whataboutism, but if you're worried about that, factory farms are a lot worse and a lot more common.