Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Fins 2611 days ago
Smart (in the usual understanding of smart), or good programmers (in the "can invert a binary tree on a whiteboard" sense)? These are two measures that are basically orthogonal.
1 comments

As in very intelligent.
Is there any evidence of that? Google selects people based on entirely different criteria, and promotes them for moving a button in Gmail from an inconvenient location to an even less convenient one.
I've met a dozen or so Google engineers over the years and am very confident as labelling them all as quite clearly very intelligent.

I'm surprised we're even having this conversation.

Might depend on your definition of "intelligent" though. I've met quite a few, too, including friends and relatives. Sure, they better than average programmers, but general intelligence seems to be the same as in your general college educated population. Otherwise we'd be arguing that Damore (or, say, Altheide, if one has ideological preference for one or the other) are also "very intelligent".
> Otherwise we'd be arguing that Damore (or, say, Altheide, if one has ideological preference for one or the other) are also "very intelligent".

That seems pretty likely.

I think you may be equating "good enough at programming to get hired by Google" with "generally intelligent". My point is that these are entirely different things.