Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by asveikau 2627 days ago
It's definitely true in my experience that disk operations are slower in Windows. Folks on this thread are getting flack for poor comparisons (IMO Windows is worse at lots of small files), but even when you remove that, and say, look at mostly portable code that deals with a single file, as I have seen using sqlite as an example, it does worse.

Not to mention Windows has built in antivirus reacting to all your filesystem activity by default...
1 comments
bashinator 2627 days ago
It's entirely possible to disable this by adding an exception for the WSL directory in Windows Defender. In my experience, this vastly improves IO from within linux.
link
dman 2627 days ago
Good luck convincing your employer to do this. One feature request from me in case someone from MSFT is reading - please design things so that no file modify hooks are invoked at all for files under wsl directory. Files in wsl should be in a secure sandbox by default outside the reach of any antivirus.

I have heard that system devs at Microsoft have Admin mode enabled. I think that is why they dont realise how bad the dev experience is on windows when you dont have admin. You cant turn windows indexing off, you cant exclude things from anti virus, you cant launch Application Verifier. All dev workflows should work without Admin.

link
ncmncm 2627 days ago
I am reliably informed that the top developers ay MS Research are in WSL 80% of the time.
link
dman 2627 days ago
Satya,if you are reading this - Do an experiment by taking away everyones admin privileges for two weeks. See how many people can still do their jobs. Fix every single developer use case you find that needs admin.
link
asveikau 2627 days ago
I wasn't talking about WSL at all actually. I have never used it. Disk performance is just worse on Windows. With or without defender. (And defender is the default.)
link
wtallis 2627 days ago
Based on limited testing, I think IO is slower on Windows even when there's no filesystem involved at all. The block layer is just slower, despite having so few features that it's hardly worthy of being called a layer compared to what's possible on Linux.
link
marmaduke 2627 days ago
Based on my limited testing, a VM running on a NTFS file backed disk runs just as fast natively.
link