Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by bilbo0s 2640 days ago
Again, instead of relying on speculation, we should wait to get more information.
3 comments

This isn't rumor mongering. This is straight out of Boeing's own documentation on the 737: https://www.satcom.guru/2019/04/stabilizer-trim-loads-and-ra...

When the stabilizer is extended and is being counteracted by elevator inputs, the forces on the control column make manually trimming stabilizers difficult or impossible. Boeing instructs that elevator input on the stick must be eased back in order to manually adjust the stabilizers.

Boeing documents possibilities, not what actually happened.
Yes, and?

If you object to people discussing the technical details of a plane w.r.t. the observed behaviour of that plane in an accident prior to the final report on the accident being released might I suggest....not clicking on the comment section, rather than trolling the comments on news items complaining that people are using the website for its stated purpose: to discuss the news being linked to?

And the news article we're commenting on raises the possibility that this is exactly what happened. If that doesn't make the hypothetical germane to discuss here, what can we talk about?
Why? I tend to enjoy informed speculation, that's one of the reason I visit this website.

Isn't speculation one of the things that characterizes us as humans?

Agreed. Hard not to speculate though. I personally find this stuff fascinating from a technical and human factors perspective -- the deaths are tragic of course.