[duado]

The thing is that because the highest-ROI application of machine learning is online advertising, unquestionably the two deepest pools of machine learning talent are at Google and Facebook. So this may be able to overcome the obvious culture mismatch between "move fast and break things" and the FDA.

[skwb]

Google has a long long history of failing in the medical space. They tend to overengineer their products in a way that makes sense if you’re a computer engineer, but not if you understand anything about the healthcare system. Facebook has no legitimate history developing these products either. It’s more involved to develop health products than it is to sell ads. And when it comes to deep learning, optimizing your ml for 2D rbg is not the same beast as volumetric 3D data.

And besides, let’s say tomorrow they have a method to do it tomorrow: how do they prospectively scam patients? How do they deploy the algorithm in a clinical setting? For any of this as a product to work, it would have to be integrated into a mri controller. Unless I’m eating my words at RSNA this year and deep mind is presenting their work, I’ll remain highly skeptical that this is going anywhere beyond a PR story that’s been sold to the media.