Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by 29ssyg 2639 days ago
I'm getting lots of 500 errors on Google Plus these hours, so maybe they're not getting throttled, just Google servers crapping out.
3 comments

When we turned down the G+ API we injected synthetic errors in increasing fractions of requests a few days ahead of the actual turndown to alert users. I'm not sure if its the same case here, but it's possible that's what's happening.
Isn't G+ due to be shutdown in two days?
Yes and it seems that's what Archive Team has been trying to archive.
Consumer G+, yes, which is what the archive is about.

The service itself will continue as a paid product "G Suite Google+".

Context comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19539373

G Suite Google+ only has a few thousands of users compared to common Google+, which has had more than 200 million.
Source?

The core G+ userbase was vastly smaller.

(I've done, and am continuing to do, estimation of that.)

There were 3.4 billion profiles, about 110-120 million ever posted anything publicly, but it was a much smaller core of 50-100k who were posting 50-100 times monthly (roughly 1-3x daily). And I figure a large share of that was span churn (the 50-100k was basically a month's worth of activity, and the attrition rate of active profiles was high).

We're collecting metrics of active G+ users through the shutdown, and that's, various:

4650 or so registered to the Google+ Mass Migration community on G+ (main migration community), since October 2018. (I'm a mod/owner).

12,000 at Pluspora (since Sept 2018)

38,000 signed the Change.org petition.

MeWe and a few other sites claim upwards of 10,000 G+ registrations, though they don't give sources or retention rates. Given that you have to sign in just to see content that's ... probably inflated.

Exodus communities in various places tend to be in the tens to 100s of members, from what I've seen (and again, I've been compiling sets).

This all skews heavily English-language speaking (though not necessarily native), and G+ was huge among Spanish, Arabic, Indonesian, Japanese, and Chinese speakers based on some indicators (mostly Community titles -- I've archive 8.1 million of those).

Upshot: if G Suite hits 10k or so members, that's an appreciable fraction of the core community G+ base, and might be more strongly motivated to use and like the product. Though of course, it's not public Internet.

(I'm frankly not a fan, but I do have a good sense of the numbers.)

> Google servers crapping out.

This seems....highly unlikely for Google.

If they don't view G+ as an important product and it's about to be shut down, it wouldn't surprise me if they set an aggressively low quota on its compute and storage resources. Google internally bills teams and product groups for services they use, AFAIK.
Throughout the years I’ve seen most if not all Google services have glitches or go down completely.
Google has all sorts of awesome things, but fault proof hardware is not achievable in the real world.
You've never opened Youtube, have you?