Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by brandonmenc 2647 days ago
As someone who is pretty hyped up for the Kyra, this stuff is really just hype.

Hype, in the sense that it's anything more than a way to hit a higher level of performance at a smaller budget of dollars and/or watts. Which, is a fine goal. But you can have a gazillion more oscillators and way better resolution with a desktop-class processor. None of these new FPGA synths will sound better than Omnisphere - but they will sound way better than the previous generation of hardware synths.

There's kind of a backlash against laptops in music right now - ex: modular and the DAW-less trend - so tons of people want hardware, and plenty of them are yelling "FPGA! FPGA!" like it makes a qualitative difference. Seriously, people on synth message boards are like, "what would this sound like if we did it with FPGA?"

I admit that sometimes there is something intangibly great about using hardware versus a laptop - but it's mostly about the interface, not the sound engine.

1 comments

> Seriously, people on synth message boards are like, "what would this sound like if we did it with FPGA?"

Ah, the blockchain of digital music.