Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by zamadatix 2652 days ago
Choice is "do you want to <x> or <y>" not "if you don't want <x> figure out how to implement <y> on your own". That's simply known as "doing the work yourself" and is largely possible on even closed sourced systems assuming you have rights on the box.

There is nothing wrong with that but it shouldn't be conflated as choice and paraded as success of such.

1 comments

The GP is referring to all the other Linux distributions who really give you <y> (or <z> or <Þ>), not to implementing <y> on your own.

There are distributions (e.g. Linux from Scratch) for when the option you want is the NULL option—i.e., doing things yourself. But there are N other managed options, not just one managed option and NULL.

Ah yes, the strawman disto which matches exactly what <user> needs and is the reason <problem> isn't actually an issue since they can just switch to strawman distro!

Unfortunately strawman distro is never real and the problems still exist after congratulating the ability to switch to it.