[cmurf]

I follow all of this, but something doesn't pass the smell test. Disclaimer, I'm a pilot, former CFII, but I don't have much knowledge about aircraft certification requirements.

I cannot comprehend feature XYZ that helps achieve aircraft certification, that can also be disabled by the pilot. Either feature XYZ is mandatory for certification or it isn't.

I can imagine a feature that provides better handling behavior or safeguarding. But if it can go crazy in a way that it's routine to disable such a feature, it must be mandatory the pilot know about the feature's operation, and they must demonstrate competency at handling the aircraft when the feature is enabled and disabled.

And all of that tells me I don't know the full story yet.

[VBprogrammer]

I don't think disabling MCAS (or electric stab trim) should be routine. Given most airliners have given up putting trim wheels in the cockpit I'm sure the reliability of electric trim is very high.

Reading between the lines this system was added as a bit of an after thought. There are plenty of systems which have control of trim so I think they probably didn't give it the respect due to stabilizer trim.

There is always the possibility we haven't got the full story. I'm going to check the full preliminary report from Lion air but from what I've read there is some strange behaviours on the trim system that aren't fully explained yet, even by this half baked fix.