Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by posterboy 2662 days ago
My thought exactly. The problem with low frequencies is the large wavelength. The size of the damper needs to be roughly proportional to the frequency for reasons I don't remember.

If I had to guess I'd say that standing waves don't leave the chamber.

It will also capture only a limited volume.

> The mathematically designed, 3D-printed acoustic metamaterial is shaped in such a way that it sends incoming sounds back to where they came from, Ghaffarivardavagh and Zhang say.

That's certainly not what a sound engineer wants. The usecases are a little different, containing noise in an MRI machine (which has low freq rumbles) or away from ground for a drone. The word droning sound is probably not a chance homophone.

They can scale the structure as needed, so potentially for low frequs, and fit many next to each other to form a wall.

The helical structure in the ring is like a long winded pipe I guess? It's literally analogue to an electronic low pass filter from an inductor in series between source and ground, without a recipient. What a sound studio needs instead is a capacitor to ground in parallel to the recipient.

1 comments

I'd need to some more research material to confirm this but I wanna say that the structure seems to exploit some effects that you can't reason with lumped model + T-line models.