[mirroredfate1]

Bugs are easy.... you just point out the bug and move on... design flaws are hard... it's hard to bring up the fact that while yes, your module solves this one immediate problem, it was written so rigidly that two sprints from now the whole thing will need to be re-written scratch. Or maybe you took a particular approach that seemed easy to implement, but it won't do async stuff properly and so it needs to be re-worked from the ground up. And I get you solved your immediate problem for your immediate task, but whoever works on this next is going to have to completely re-think the approach and that's not theoretical, that next week when we add more behavior.

You ever worked on a team a where someone would go write code in their own crazy way that wouldn't follow any sort of existing pattern or take advantage of existing tooling? So they spend like a week on a simple task because they re-wrote the strings.c because they didn't want to include it? Yeah, they get fired eventually, but they are the worst to write code reviews for, because you go into it just thinking WTH, why are they doing it this way, this entire approach is convoluted and error-prone and rigid and fragile and complicated.

If a super engineer has advice for me on how to deal with this stuff, I'm all ears. I usually just ignore it unless it directly impacts me and then go back and re-write it when we have to add on to it/make it interop with some more code/release it as an available API.

[aristophenes]

I had a coworker who had a 2,000 line PR that took me 3 days to review, it was like code breaking. Custom abstractions upon custom abstractions, abstractions in custom imported utilities for a one-liner that was only used once. Basically, instead of writing the code, he made code that generated the code that was needed, once the program was running. Dear Lord. Like somehow this monstrosity was good because instead of creating the feature, he built tooling to make many identical features whenever we want! Except nothing can be different, if it's different we need to rewrite the whole thing.

Every 4 hours or so I would ask my boss if I really had to do it. He told me to just keep going, I think he was building a case for letting him go. I still only made like 10 comments, needless to say they weren't taken well. What a nightmare.

Tangential to this whole thread, but guys like that, every day he worked took two days for other devs to fix/undo his work. Took my company a few years to catch on, he was a senior dev and also good at talking himself up. I would have paid him the same salary to go sit on a beach somewhere and enjoy himself instead of touching the code, we'd all have been happier. In fact the world would be a better place, because now he is presumably working somewhere else doing the same things.