[hopler]

It's not transphobic to question whether a women-only organization should include transwomen. It's a legitimately hard question with no 100% correct answer. You have to deal with the possibility of people who identify as female according to their own standards, which you might consider dishonest or confused.

[alliecat]

Step off it, mate.

There is a correct answer: People who call themselves women are women. Simple as that.

You're not the arbiter of Gender.

[tomp]

So Trump can be the first female president... if he wants?

[alliecat]

Sure. Trump's an abhorrent human being but that doesn't stop me from respecting their gender identity.

I don't go around misgendering people I don't like because I don't like them. That's shit.

[tomp]

Well let's agree to disagree. To me, "man" and "women" mean sex (i.e. biologically male or female human), not gender.