Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by woogiewonka 2701 days ago
As a designer who often hands over designs to developers, I find it all too frequent scenarios where developers struggle interpreting design into code. I have NEVER seen a developer who can implement a design exactly per spec in CSS.

This is not to say that developers are incompetent with CSS, in fact, it probably says more about CSS than it does about the developer. The fact that CSS has gotten so convoluted is counter to its original goal.

Perhaps I have just work with companies who don't have an A-class developer team? I don't know. But it's not unusual for developers to straight up tell me "I'm not a CSS guy". Like... really? Who is then?

1 comments

As both a designer and primarily a developer I can tell you there hasn't been a design I couldn't implement exactly as per spec over several years.

The issue has been more a case of it would be better not to and the design being incomplete (being most frequently static mocks) it hasn't fully captured the interaction, all scenarios or device widths. Designers need to really understand the medium they are working with and meet devs halfway.

Good design is function over form and working within constraints. All too often in the industry the designs are created as though they are for print. This is in large part also due to the fact designers tooling itself was designed for print and we are just now beginning to have better tools for designing interfaces but there is a long long way to go.