Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by drc37 2712 days ago
But why do you feel it is your right or the right of the government to take it from them? Because they happen to be more successful than you? I have never understood the logic of taking from the rich because they are rich. That always sparks the idea of true laziness in the person saying this.
1 comments

That's kind of a weirdly confrontational tone to take.

If you already believe that "taxes are theft", then nothing I or anyone else can say will change your mind.

However, the fact is that you made your money in one of the most money-making-amenable contexts in the history of this planet, and that's not an accident, and it's not a coincidence. This nation has been investing in itself--and investing in you--since long before either of us were born, in order to provide the societal context that allowed you to exercise the full extent of your god-given abilities in order to make your fortune. That's why you didn't die of cholera when you were 3, it's why you didn't join the job market as a barefoot and illiterate 12-year-old, it's why you can commute to work each day secure in the knowledge that some dude isn't going to pull up in a Toyota Hilux, jack your Beemer and sell you into slavery.

To be a rich person in the United States and think "I made all this money, all by myself, because I'm some kind of genius Randian super-guy" is the pinnacle of deluded, parasitical vanity.

First sentence:

> That's kind of a weirdly confrontational tone to take.

Last sentence:

> To be a rich person in the United States and think "I made all this money, all by myself, because I'm some kind of genius Randian super-guy" is the pinnacle of deluded, parasitical vanity.

You see that as non confrontational?

Yes. The person to whom I was responding was not speaking rationally, unfortunately.

Could you parse this sentence for me please? "That always sparks the idea of true laziness in the person saying this."