Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by bdcravens 2708 days ago
You'd still have to bundle a JS engine. Presumably you could build a traditional UI app and include V8, but I still think this isn't a bad use case for Electron (but I agree there are many apps where it isn't the best choice)
1 comments

I'd imagine that the browser is the resource-heavy part of the application, Nodejs doesn't use hundreds of mb's of RAM in my experience, at least not while doing very little background work.

To me it would make sense to build a real desktop application and bundle whatever JS engine you want to use, pipe and process the output as any other application.

You'd end up with a much smaller application (Download size), more resource-efficient, and less reliance on things like the bundled browser.

> You'd end up with a much smaller application (Download size), more resource-efficient, and less reliance on things like the bundled browser.

None of these things I care about. I care about whether or not it serves a purpose to me. If it does, I'll use it. If it doesn't, I won't. You might have other priorities and that's your prerogative.