Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Latteland 2727 days ago
Sounds believable that countries do these alerts for sometimes political reasons, but China is actually keeping people from leaving the country for unspecified reasons and is seizing people, even their own citizens.
3 comments

Plenty of countries do bad things to their own citizens that have absolutely no impact on foreign tourists who visit.

I'm not saying it's OK, but it's hardly a reason to warn people not to go there.

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/19/us/politics/china-canada-...

China has been holding 3 Canadian's, likely in retaliation to the CFO of Huawei being held. So it may seem warranted here?

The reason why those seizures are happening is why this "escalatory" bulletin is newsworthy.

This is another bullet point in an escalation trend we've been seeing between the West and China, mostly surrounding infrastructure and political pressure/flurries of arrests and high profile detainments, in both regions.

China is issuing the same warning to Chinese citizens traveling to US
And which Chinese citizens are we holding hostage in retaliation for an exec being jailed?
China's warning is related with US randomly violence, gun shooting, robbery etc (if you understand Chinese: http://www.china-embassy.org/chn/lszj/zytz/t1597786.htm). US and China are very different countries, like in China, the downtown of metropolis is very safe at night, but in US is totally different. And also, gun shooting in US is really normal, but extremely rare in China.
This reads like an faq for people coming to US. First item reminds people to buy travel/health insurance. Second item warns against going out alone in late night. Etc. I didn't see anything political in it.
But VOA think that's not normal, and it's a political signal. Do you believe? https://www.voachinese.com/a/news-us-china-travel-20180703/4...