Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by yorwba 2726 days ago
> it's time to fork FF and get rid of all their garbage.

The nice thing about Firefox is that you don't even need to fork for that.

> Make Pocket optional

Go to about:config and set extensions.pocket.enabled to false.

> remove the (paid?) list of URLs that's apparently preloaded

If you mean the stuff that's displayed on new tab pages (like the snippet in TFA), you can get rid of it by changing "Firefox Home Content" at about:preferences#home .

> remove all of the phone home shit

I've deliberately enabled all telemetry, because I think it's data that Mozilla should have (check about:telemetry to see what they're measuring) but you can disable it under "Firefox Data Collection and Use" at about:preferences#privacy .

I agree it'd be better if Firefox came with a sane configuration by default, but the fact that you can change it at all makes Firefox a good enough browser for me.
2 comments
switch007 2726 days ago
I think it's completely fair to judge Firefox by its defaults though, because I imagine a tiny percentage will fully tweak their about:config to more privacy-conscious settings, and that percentage will go down the more non-technical people install it.
link
Tharkun 2726 days ago
> Go to about:config and set extensions.pocket.enabled to false.

That doesn't remove Pocket, it merely disables it. It's a stupid feature and a stupid default. It should be an extension that users can choose to install (or not).

> remove the (paid?) list of URLs that's apparently preloaded

This might be an android thing only, but when I type, for instance "sea", the URL bar autocomplete will suggest "sears.com", even though I have search disabled and have never visited sears.com. There are a bunch of these which seem to have come out of nowhere.

link
yorwba 2726 days ago
> This might be an android thing only, but when I type, for instance "sea", the URL bar autocomplete will suggest "sears.com", even though I have search disabled and have never visited sears.com. There are a bunch of these which seem to have come out of nowhere.

I honestly never noticed this, because I look at the keyboard when I type a URL on Android.

Doing a bit of research in Bugzilla, it appears that there are two different systems in Firefox to "seed" the browser with autocomplete results. The first was implemented in Fennec (Firefox Android) [1] and acts as a fallback to the Alexa top 500 sites if no other autocomplete result was found [2]. The second was implemented separately in all of Firefox [3]. Ironically, someone was worried whether this might appear to users as a paid advertisement, but proposed using engagement as a metric to measure the impact [4]. That implementation uses browser.urlbar.usepreloadedtopurls.enabled and .expire_days to stop using the preloaded list after two weeks (when the user probably has generated enough history of their own). But the earlier Fennec version doesn't respect those settings. Someone already complained about that [5], but it doesn't appear like they filed the report in the right place for someone on the Fennec team to see it.

I'm going to file a new report to hopefully get that fixed. In the meantime you can toggle browser.urlbar.autocomplete.enabled to completely disable autocomplete, but I guess you might not want that if the suggestions are otherwise useful.

[1] https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=858829

[2] https://hg.mozilla.org/mozilla-central/file/tip/mobile/andro...

[3] https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1211726

[4] https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1211726#c10

[5] https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1211726#c70

link