Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jostmey 2731 days ago
How did they determine vaping is 95% less harmful than smoking? I don't see references to the methods they used to make this assessment. Where did that number come from? As far as I can tell, the number was just made up!
2 comments

Here is Dr Rosemary’s twitter, she was quoted, you can ask her

https://twitter.com/DrRosemaryL

No, Dr Rosemary is not quoted in the article as coming up with the number 95%. That number is mentioned before she is quoted or her name is used
Call me when multiple longitudinal studies independently verify that opinion.
Ah ok

She mentione that it is much less harmful

Still not quantified with a source, maybe she knows one

You do know the number 95% comes very frequently from statistical analysis right?
You know putting "right" at the end turns your comment from helpful to dickish, right?
It comes up at least 95% of the time when discussing statistical analysis.
You may be referring to p-values, and the arbitrary 0.05 threshold but in that case, the connection is risky at best and wrong in general (common misinterpretation of p-value as probability of alternative being false)