Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by xpaulbettsx 2731 days ago
It's bananas that people are downmodding you on this point. A financial system or security / commodity that literally has no recourse in the face of crime or even simple clerical error, is an unusable financial system. Can you imagine if everyone who had a credit card stolen was just liable for anything bought?
3 comments

And a financial system that allows some group somewhere to decide if i'm allowed to buy (or sell!) some things, can lock my funds at any time for many reasons, and can track and sell information about what and where I bought things to any number of various 3rd parties is also similarly "unusable" for some.

It's a tradeoff like anything else. For some people, the risk is worth the benefit. For others it's not. Still more find the risk worth the benefits for a subset of their money, and not for the rest.

All of these "financial systems" can happily coexist, and none of them are completely broken, they just prioritize different things and make different tradeoffs.

Also, bitcoin doesn't require being a lawless land where everyone can do anything all the time. It's like cash, but electronic.

If a thief breaks into your house and steals $10,000 in cash, will the police give you $10,000? If they find the guy and he still has it, sure! But what if he burned it? or spent it? now you are fucked.

It's the same with bitcoin. if they catch the person who did this, the courts can force him to return the money with threat of lots of jail time and more. If he doesn't have it, then the users that had it stolen are fucked.

you are comparing apples to oranges.
Cash has the same properties and people have been using it for millennia.
I wouldn't advocate going to a 100% cash-only system either in 2018, and neither would any other reasonable individual
cash is a physical entity, though -- i'm not sure there's a parallel to be drawn there
lots of HN'ers bought into the FOMO

and now they are caught holding bags

a future which has no real use cases.