Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by fao_ 2735 days ago
Why not just read the unencrypted data that the Blu-ray players give you, though.
1 comments

Like, ripping the HDMI output? You're limited to realtime speed for that, which is going to make the process take ten times longer.
Plus, critiacally, that signal is the result of the player messing around with the data. It might do all kinds of stupid processing. You don’t know what quality of decoder they’ve put in the player. I guess there are ways to find out so It’s not a dealbreaker but it’s just another thing that complicates stuff. But overall I’d say that finding a player with really good decoding and capturing the resulting signal is your best option for the scenario I outlined. It wouldn’t make a difference if it took 2 minutes or two hours because the window between getting a movie and mailing it back is way more than two hours.
> But overall I’d say that finding a player with really good decoding and capturing the resulting signal is your best option for the scenario I outlined.

Exactly.

Also HDCP becomes an issue.
You can get HDMI splitters on Amazon that will get rid of HDCP.