Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Wowfunhappy 2744 days ago
GDPR really should only apply to companies beyond a certain size. Or at least, the requirements for small companies should be less stringent.
4 comments

Small companies can and do abuse personal data just as well.

I'll never forget how some period tracking app that my partner was using was updated with much more invasive privacy policy terms. It was take it or leave it, no way to use the app any more except by clicking the accept button.

It was a small European start up that did this.

So yes, GDPR applies to all sizes of companies.

That would be exploited SO FAST!

Embed my 1-person company's widget. I will collect everything and send it to big boys.

Same way as you funnel money through a shell corp to avoid taxes.

In the US, we have rules to stop this sort of thing for e.g. background check data. If you collect personally identifiable information from a third party, it's the same as if you collected it yourself.
Why should small companies be able to collect user data without consent?
The requirements for small companies are less stringent.
> The requirements for small companies are less stringent.

Conditioning various minor requirements on entity size is no help if they don't actually reduce the complexity. Otherwise the cost of determining what they have to comply with is as expensive as the cost of determining what they have to do to comply.

What smaller entities need is an entirely separate framework with fewer, simpler, narrower rules that don't have to be as robust against a huge team of lawyers finding loopholes because smaller entities don't have a huge team of lawyers finding loopholes.

Then you can have an entirely different set of robust arbitrarily complex rules that all only apply to companies with more than 1000 employees because they can afford to handle the complexity.