Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by root_axis 2749 days ago
Politically, I agree with you, but your comment is akin to when republicans blast global warming when a snow storm blows in. Pointing to a single data point as a summary of something super complex is always silly.
3 comments

It's comments like this that keep me coming back to Hacker News. I sometimes find myself in political discussions with people and feel that they aren't playing fair for whatever reason (fair in the sense of good natured truth-seeking). Your counter-example is the perfect, non-snarky retort.
Argumentum ad populum or ad numerum, it's always good to keep an eye for them!
That's a fair criticism. One wave of layoffs does not constitute evidence that the tax cuts are a failure.

Still the economy is going in an upward direction, and Verizon isn't shrinking. Why are they laying off 10K people?

Verizon has seen zero revenue growth since something like 2012 or 2013. 7% employee cut, against a 12%-14% inflation erosion of their business. Everything they've done over that time has been to just stand still while T-Mobile eats their market out from under them.

In a more practical consideration, they're very likely going to need less people going forward because they're going to keep losing market share to a more nimble competitor. They'd be the last to admit that of course.

They're the most expensive carrier in a highly competitive market that will likely get more so in the next 3-5 years.
A rising economy can't compensate for stupid executive decisions.
Are Republics a homogenous whole, none of whom take climate change seriously?
Of course not, but invoking cold weather as a way of casting doubt on global warming is not a popular rhetorical tactic except among American conservatives (republicans).
Today, everyone is in a group, and if that group is not your group, the other group is bad.
Today? Did you mean literally the entire history of humanity?