[kllrnohj]

> On Unity's case with some subsystems in the process of being replaced by HPC#.

They are converting their C# code to HPC# which specifically does not do GC allocations.

https://youtu.be/NF6kcNS6U80?t=886

  HPC#:
   * no class types
   * no boxing
   * no GC allocation
   * not exceptions for control flow

They are building a compiler to eliminate the GC from the GC'd language they were using.

[pjmlp]

Once upon a time, C code for games engines looked like this.

    void do_stuff(void) {
        asm {
        }
    }

Hardly any C code in sight, and most of the stuff could equally have been coded in MASM/TASM with their higher level macros.

Eventually game devs migrated to proper C.

A couple of years later, C++ code in game engines, was not even "C with Classes", rather C compiled with C++ compiler.

Eventually game devs migrated to proper C++.

Looking at the past, which I was partially part of, I see HPC# as a stepping stone into regular C#, in a similar vein that C code of yore was full of inline Assembly.

It is of course a matter of opinion, however I like to look at the past to see where the future leads to.

So lets see who's is right in about 10 years, regarding how game engines get implemented.

[kllrnohj]

Except they are stepping AWAY from C# here, not towards it.

And the game-industry as a whole is moving to data-oriented design, which tends to be hard to do at best (if not downright impossible) in most GC'd languages.

Regardless the transition from C to C++ has no performance cost (often a performance advatnage), so I'm not sure why you're bringing that up as some significant migration in this case? It doesn't support any argument for a transition from C++ to C# or similar, as that comes with a huge performance cost. Particularly in an era where CPU performance hasn't improved for almost a decade now.

[pjmlp]

Modern CPU performance gets explored by taking advantage of multi-core, and GC is a very helpful tool for writing lock-free data structures.

Additionally dataflow languages are better suited for GPGPU programming than plain old C and C++, as Google is exploring with XLA on Tensorflow, and game engines with graphical tooling for shader generation.

Again, lets come back in 10 years and see who was actually right.