Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by xte 2753 days ago
Perhaps my poor English make hard for me to clearly express concepts, sorry. How to do your nails it's simply far less valuable than how a banks or a car work in knowledge terms, however on YT&c it get far more financial reward than a video on banking systems, mechanics etc.

Home that's more clear.

1 comments

I don’t think it’s has less value on a case by case basis, but this is also not relevant.

There is a big difference between education/enrichment and entertainment and while some content creators might walk the line between them there is a pretty big split.

I would say pre-defining what is “valuable” is probably not the best approach because it too prone to selection bias, an instruction video on how to do nails to a beautician is far more useful than a video explaining correspondenant banking systems.

That said the content as a whole can be measured in terms of its impact on cognitive and emotional state and well being especially on large sample sizes.

We already know that social media voyeurism causes a lot emotional distress, we know that certain types of content can make you “dumber” at least in the short term.

And on a larger scale we can check the social and individual benefits for specific cases, e.g. how many individuals who watched a specific subeset of content turned their life to the better in say a period of 5 years.