Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tinus_hn 2754 days ago
X is not perfect so it must be broken by design. Better not use it, instead follow these impossible steps!
3 comments

It advertises itself as "prevent Google from tracking you around the web", which I consider a false and misleading statement. It doesn't prevent it. It is not "not perfect", it is not even far from perfect.

I think it is very important to make Internet users aware that cookies are the red herring in all privacy issues that are plaguing the World Wide Web. Cookie feature in modern browsers is just a tiny puzzle piece in a larger picture, consisting of wide range of entry points used for collecting data. It includes invasive JavaScript fingerprinting that can easily extract a list of installed fonts, local IP address and list of media devices from WebRTC, device capabilities, WebGL/Canvas fingerprinting, content filter list detection and much much more. Even with JS disabled most browsers share so much explicit information that is enough for precise identification without the use of cookies.

Is it impossible? For 99.99% of Internet users it requires so much hoops to hop through it might as well be impossible. However, I believe that awareness could slow down this privacy decline. I hope users will finally start demanding more native privacy controls in their browsers. Native JavaScript filter in Firefox would be a good place to start.

They aren’t impossible steps, just get virtualbox for sites you don’t want tracking you. Unless they can break out of the VM they can’t fingerprint the hardware even if JavaScript is enabled
IP address, screen size, etc. will still be the same in the VM no?
Not to mention the attributes of the VM itself will then be used for tracking.
How exactly would you use the attributes of a VM for tracking? You can have a separate one for fb and for google. All they are going to be able to track is what you want them to know
Not exactly impossible, the Tor browser for example implements many if not all of these.
Do you have much experience using the tor browser? I think it’s a good example of why it’s impossible.
Yes indeed, I've generally found it quite good - what's the issue? You don't like dealing with NoScript or something?

I have that even on my regular browser...

ReCaptchas, the inability to post to many sites because tor ip addresses have been blacklisted, latency, etc. It’s better than nothing but like many solutions it doesn’t really seem to address the underlying problem.
Those have absolutely nothing to do with the Tor browser though nor any of the solutions mentioned, that's simply IP blacklisting.

The underlying problem of privacy is addressed. The consequence of anonymity is a lack of trust.