[ravenstine]

There seems to be a misunderstanding with what I'm talking about. I'm not saying that phone screenings shouldn't be about qualifications. My point is that if through that process I'm made to feel like a number, that gives me a bad impression of the rest of the business relationship. If the person doing the screening comes off as friendly, maybe enthusiastic, and we can have a pleasant 2 way chat, then I'm much more likely to move forward with the process.

To provide contrast, I had a phone screening yesterday where the screener was only asking yes/no questions that were easily answered by my resume, didn't want me to go into much detail, and didn't seem friendly at all. Why would I want to move forward with that company? There are others where I can tell off the bat that they'd be a better culture fit. First impressions do matter.

One of the things I like about a video screening is it usually changes the tone of the conversation towards being a bit less formal.

[scarface74]

My point is that if through that process I'm made to feel like a number

You are a number as an employee, we are all just disposable pieces of the cog. The business transaction is simple. I’ll stay there as long as they are putting money in my account twice a month that is commensurate with my market value and I know they will keep me employed as long as it is in their best interest.

You are just one of a pile of resumes that they are filtering at any one time.