Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by darawk 2770 days ago
> Its a generally well documented trend that once rich it becomes difficult to actually fall out of wealth. I'd definitely love some unbiased research in how much better these purported rich people are better at allocating capital.

Huh? The fact that they're rich is proof.

> Because I can easily start naming microeconomically selfish ways of managing capital that the wealthy practice on the regular that it is no way economically beneficial to the parent economy - offshore tax havens, tax loopholes, real estate bubbles, buying politicians and policy to harm liberty, investing in companies that themselves offshore, launder, and hide their capital outside of the economy.

Sure, but they had to get rich in the first place.

> Businesses in the US are magnitudes wealthier today than they were forty years ago but the standard of living has at best remained stagnant for the last 20 (depending on locality, there are substantial regional swings). Money is flush in the upper echelons of society but it has provably and demonstrably not resulted in economic prosperity for the whole nation.

Yes, its been very unevenly distributed. How do you think that relates to the question at hand?

2 comments

"Sure, but they had to get rich in the first place."

That can be achieved by being born with the right parents, not necessarily by doing intelligent things.

> That can be achieved by being born with the right parents, not necessarily by doing intelligent things.

Again, exceptions are irrelevant. We're talking about the aggregate here.

You have yet to prove that those are exceptions.
That's because it's self-evident. People get rich by allocating capital effectively. QED.
What is self-evident is that you're just trolling, and have no interest in actual discourse. QED.
Do you not understand the issue? I'm not trolling. You become wealthy by allocating capital efficiently. This is econ 101. How hard is this to understand?
> Huh? The fact that they're rich is proof.

A certain popular politician/business owner has filed bankruptcy 6 times.

> Sure, but they had to get rich in the first place.

That's easy, just be born that way.

Again...the fact that some people are born that way does not preclude the fact that the aggregate group has better capital allocation capabilities than the average person.