| That's a really interesting thought experiment, and I don't really know what my answer is. The following choices assume that more people living an extra 30 years is a good thing ethically, and that there are no devastating effects environmentally or otherwise. The following choices also assume that you'll always have a monopoly on the production of the drug. 1. Assuming that the supply is practically unlimited, an altruistic actor should probably give it away for as close to free as possible. A purely selfish actor should probably try to sell to each individual for as much as they can afford (though this can be hard pricing strategy to enact). I suppose you might actually want to charge less than that even as a purely selfish actor, since you wouldn't want to somehow destroy the world economy by making everyone really poor except for yourself (would this actually destroy the economy though? I'm not sure... probably not relevant for the purposes of this thought experiment). 2. Assuming supply is limited, a purely altruistic actor will have to choose the most fitting recipients. This is a really tough choice. How do you define the most fitting recipients? Those who are most likely to contribute to the betterment of humanity with their extra 30 years? It seems like an almost impossible task to pick out who these people would be. A purely selfish actor should charge the richest as much as they're willing to pay. If it were me and supply were unlimited, I'd like to think that I'd sell it for as little as possible but enough to still never have to worry about money again. Making $10 million in profit would probably be more than enough (though if you can make more and still help everyone, that'd be even better). If supply were limited, I don't know what I would do. One thing I just realized though, is that even if supply were unlimited, if you had this godly power, you might choose to withhold it those you deem unworthy, which is a whole other ethical can of worms. I'm guessing this kind of deviates from the intent of your thought experiment though. What's your answer? |