Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by GenerationRous 2781 days ago
If they really believe in their ideals, they should do the hard work to change the laws in their favor, or cleverly use already existing ones, instead of childishly isolating themselves from society and the government as outlaws.

There is a precedent for this: the 18th and 19th century religious communes -- some of them anarchist -- had popular support and were able to change US laws so that they could avoid taxes and live in peace as gated utopias in the way they wanted -- because they didn't antagonize the rest of society or the US government.

Or, put another way, they were anarchists that did politics maturely and succeeded (even though their utopias didn't).

1 comments

Utopian societies in pre-20th century USA were typically located in isolated settlements. Armed conflict was typical unless it was a group specifically dedicated to nonviolent ideals. Cf. the "Mormon wars" and pro/anti abolitionist movements in Western territories