Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by yourbandsucks 2785 days ago
I didn't see OPs original rant, it's been flagged. I'm assuming there was something in there about how awful Chinese people are because placenta?

As far as it being a thing.. I'm pretty sure historically it's a really big thing. Protein is expensive for subsistence farmers. Too bad OP lost their lunch over it
2 comments
PavlovsCat 2785 days ago
> I'm assuming there was something in there about how awful Chinese people are because placenta?

Exactly that.

link
browsercoin 2785 days ago
PavlovsCat wrote a very generalizing statement about what "Asians" eat and then tried to smear it on me. It was a thinly veiled racism but then again people from UK doesn't seem to have a good grip on what is considered racist in North America. What he wrote would fall under sneaky bigotry. Not full blown racism but I'm used to seeing dogwhistling on reddit.

I only wrote that the corrupt Chinese elite exploit the people including taking prisoners organs, prostitution, all sorts of human rights abuse.

but somehow it's been derived to that removed comment which implied that I didn't view Mainland China unfavorably, please don't try to conflate it with sinophobia, I haven't made that case at all, it's just apalling behavior from the Communist party of China that pisses me off because it pains me to see what my Chinese friends go through.

link
PavlovsCat 2785 days ago
> PavlovsCat wrote a very generalizing statement about what "Asians" eat

I said I considered it possible because of the powdered animals stuff [0]. That's not even a statement about "what Asians eat", much less a generalizing one.

[0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2014/08/08/extinctio...

> It was a thinly veiled racism

I said I "totally could see it being a thing in Asia". Call that racism if you must, but there is nothing "veiled" here.

> I only wrote that the corrupt Chinese elite exploit the people including taking prisoners organs, prostitution, all sorts of human rights abuse

Yeah, and you put it like this

> the poor sick Chinese elite (they actually eat the fucking placenta for supposedly viagra effect jesus fucking christ im outta here never EVER gonna catch me going to China)

(anyone can turn on "showdead" and still see the comment, you know that, right?)

Sure, technically I guess "they" refers to the Chinese elite. Insofar I accept your correction. But still, way, I actually looked something up real quick that even you, who made the claim, apparently knew nothing about... and as I said, I only "shared what I found" because it refutes any stereotypes about only Asian or Chinese people doing that, heh.

Anyways, back to a vegan Alicia Silverstone eating her placenta; I find that by itself infinitely more fascinating than any of whatever this is.

link
yourbandsucks 2785 days ago
Like I said, I didn't see your original comment. All I'll say is that I encourage you to listen to people who've lived in China about Chinese problems rather than just overlaying an American worldview.

Edit: oh nevermind, I can see the comment now. Shame on you.

link