Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by cetico 2782 days ago
MMA is new, historically speaking.

BJJ is the best fighting style that fits the rules of MMA. Change the rules a bit and a different style will work better.

1 comments

Whats the minimal change in the rules that will bring a striking based martial art to the top?
I would guess, the following rule changes will help a lot.

* Increase the minimum size of the wrist padding and gloves. Which makes it much safer to throw punches. Additionally, the design of the gloves can be regulated so grabbing someone is harder than it is now.

* Perhaps, add rules about how long you can stay on top of someone on the ground without doing significant damage. A lot of matches end up with a takedown at the start of a round followed by 3 minutes of light pounding and no serious attempt/success at a submission hold. A 20-30 second limit on no serious on the ground action will go a long way.

* Finally, we can directly change the judging criteria to make it easier to win rounds via striking dominance instead of grappling.

One of the more famous Royce Gracie wins was against a western wrestler (Severn) who maintained control on top for almost all of the 15 minute match before being caught in a triangle choke.
Allow kicking or kneeing someone in the face when they're down?
I am not sure if such is allowed in another martial arts league. But from my experience in fighting, kicking someone anywhere on the body while they are on the ground will quickly and inevitably result in serious injuries. Standing up, you can "elastically catch" the kick and reduce the damage it does. On the floor, you will absorb the full force.
Which is why the rules exist, and why MMA is wrestling/boxing, not a martial art. Either you are training to score points within a rule system, or you are training to kill/maim/incapacitate. Don’t confuse the two.
Allow for more than one attacker.