The value that Earth provides is the fact that it hosts millions of living species.
Mere geological resources can be gathered from asteroids or other planets with lesser gravity wells.
The Alien species would have to determine if Human technology, economy and culture holds any value to them. If it does, they will conduct a cost-benefit analysis of the various billions of humans inhabiting the planet, and eliminate the least-productive in order to improve average genetic quality and bring the overall species back to within the carrying capacity of the planet.
For example, 56% of the Earth's population from the least-productive countries could be eliminated, for only a 6% decrease in scientific output, and 17% decrease in GDP. Doing so would also result in a 23% decrease in carbon emissions.
Of course, if they find that humanity holds negative value, they will simply eliminate all humans, and turn the planet into a giant nature park.
If we're talking about intelligences that can travel between stars, there is no 'carrying capacity' aside from space on the surface for radiative cooling towers to stop the planet from boiling from the heat generated by the trillions of humans and machines.
Seriously, you can probably put all the nonhuman processes of an ecosystem into a bottle that takes in air, energy, and wastewater and puts out food/crops/etc, and you can just dismantle some asteroids for the materials needed for as many fleets of solar panels as you need to put around earth, assuming they don't want to use what's powering their rockets. Really, the limiting factor is cooling the earth. You'd probably want to block all infrared from the sun for convenience.
Implying these beings would likely have any need to worry about 'decreasing' carbon emissions is ludicrous. It's like humans going to a beehive and worrying about killing some bees to stop honey wastage when the humans poke a hole in the hive to collect honey- no, they'll just completely reconstitute the hive. There's a chance it's some first-interstellar-travel thing we might do right now, but it's more likely it's from the time a civilisation is kardashev-2, given that time would be longer.
Fermi paradox's still a problem, though.
Mere geological resources can be gathered from asteroids or other planets with lesser gravity wells.
The Alien species would have to determine if Human technology, economy and culture holds any value to them. If it does, they will conduct a cost-benefit analysis of the various billions of humans inhabiting the planet, and eliminate the least-productive in order to improve average genetic quality and bring the overall species back to within the carrying capacity of the planet.
For example, 56% of the Earth's population from the least-productive countries could be eliminated, for only a 6% decrease in scientific output, and 17% decrease in GDP. Doing so would also result in a 23% decrease in carbon emissions.
Of course, if they find that humanity holds negative value, they will simply eliminate all humans, and turn the planet into a giant nature park.