Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ogre_magi 2780 days ago
>How many satellites could you knock out if you really tried?

With a single launch scattering a lot of debris?

You could reliably take out ONE satellite. The clouds of debris creating a cascade of destruction as depicted in the movie Gravity are entirely fictional.

1 comments

How about a hundred BFR sized launchers? (Just scaling it up to nation-state/Bond villain levels, out of curiosity.)
That's enough debris to choke off LEO, but it wont stay up there for very long. You'd need to refresh the debris cloud every few decades.

Edit to add:

The easier and cheaper villainous way to deny spaceflight to someone is just to shoot missiles at their spacecraft.

The easier and cheaper villainous way to deny spaceflight to someone is just to shoot missiles at their spacecraft.

Missiles can be pretty expensive, and if you go far downscale on cost and capabilities, you'll need to recruit fanatics who are willing to get caught every time a missile is fired at a spacecraft.

On the other hand, if the fleet of BFRs grows in numbers, then 100 flights of a BFR might be pretty inexpensive for a military operation that affects all strategic theaters at once.

The chief advantage of missiles, would be the ability to not shoot down your own rockets.