Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jeppz 2790 days ago
Wait, am I crazy or is that metal strip actually not a Mobius?
5 comments

as far as I can tell: no, it does not seem to be a Mobius.

Edit: They did change the image. In the last image, they showed a metal surface which wrapped two times and had not the properties of a mobius strip.

Edit 2: found it, the old image was this stock image: https://www.istockphoto.com/de/foto/moebius-streifen-in-meta...

>Edit: They did change the image. In the last image, they showed a metal surface which wrapped two times and had not the properties of a mobius strip.

This is still a single-sided surface though (with the 2 twists).

Wikipedia: "the Möbius strip can also be formed by twisting the strip an odd number of times greater than one"

Not sure about needing to be "odd", I think 2 qualifies as well, so perhaps odd or even AND prime does it...

No, it has two sides. Pick a side and trace it with your finger - you'll never get to the other side.

(I'm talking about this image, from the second edit: https://www.istockphoto.com/de/foto/moebius-streifen-in-meta... )

If you mean this picture they have in the article:

http://ichef.bbci.co.uk/wwfeatures/wm/live/624_351/images/li...

it is. Why wouldn't it be? The single "twist" in the lower right part is the distinctive sign of one.

It looks kind of swirly and hidden but it must be... but I couldn't trace it in my mind for some reason!
It is a Mobius strip.

To convince yourself it might be useful to imagine a point on the surface and imagine tracing it along the strip (avoiding the edges) and seeing if you get back to where your started.

They've changed the image, quickly, but this was the previous image, which is not a Möbius strip:

https://www.alamy.com/stock-photo-metallic-moebius-strip-iso...

Fantastic! They even coloured the faces to emphasize the fact it is NOT, in fact, a Mobius strip.
It's not xD