Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by GeneralMayhem 2804 days ago
Possibly confusion by someone who's used to the long scale? In Danish, as in most non-English European languages, the cognate of "billion" means trillion (10^12).
4 comments

As it did in British English until, I guess, some time in the 80s or 90s after the Treasury decided to standardise on the US format (edit: apparently that was in 1975).

Like with metrication us Brits adopted it slowly so there were many years of seeing either usage. This wasn't confusing at all. :)

I think there is a mathematical definition and a financial definition of a "billion".
In the US, there is only one meaning for billion. Thousands (10^3), millions (10^6), billions (10^9), trillions (10^12), quadrillions (10^15), etc. And 99% of people would have never heard of milliard or billiard or any other -ard.
No cue sports in the US?
Hah, I meant in the context of numbers.
In Sweden there's miljon ^6, miljard ^9, biljon ^12, biljard ^15 (also means pool table) and triljon ^18. I once had to ask if "milj" meant miljon or miljard and they refused to answer and said I should look it up in a dictionary. This was a government contract.
Afrikaans also uses the long system.

"miljoen" -> "miljard" -> "biljoen" -> "biljard" -> "triljoen"

^6 -> ^9 -> ^12 -> ^15 -> ^18

However, a lot of Afrikaans-speaking people use the de facto English convention. The newspapers usually get it right though, in contrast to this article.

> in most non-English European languages

i dont think that's true

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_and_short_scales#Long_sca...

The UK is the only place in Europe where "billion" means 10^9; in Eastern European languages, there simply isn't an equivalent word, and everywhere else it means 10^12.

An equivalent word for what? Poland is an EE language and has milion, miliard, bilion, biliard, etc.
in romanian it's like in French: million = milion, billion = miliard
> i dont think that's true

Here is a handy list:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_and_short_scales#Long_sca...

weird. Greek is short, not "other"
The Greek system parallels the short scale, but the terms themselves are derived from the myriad system; δισεκατομμύριο disekatommýrio, 10^9, literally reads twice-hundred-myriad.
Can confirm it's true for French and German: Million 10^6 Milliard(e) 10^9 Billion 10^12 Billiard(e) 10^15