Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by 394549 2805 days ago
This is the free market at work, throwing off its chains. /s
3 comments

Are you saying that if there wasn't a free market there wouldn't be fake products?

That's obviously false.

The free market proscribes fraud.
In the most abstract way possible: sure, in the real world: not so much.
Misrepresenting your product is fraud and is illegal in a free market.
Misrepresentation is commonplace, even outright fraud is commonplace. Serious fraud is a multi-billion dollar industry. "Light fraud" and gray area misrepresentation is at least hundreds of billions of dollars a year.
It's still illegal under a free market, and prosecutable.
The "free market" doesn't make fraud or misrepresentation illegal, the laws and regulations of the dreaded government do.

The worst the free market can do to a fraudster is to stop dealing with her as knowledge of her frauds becomes widely known. That, of course, doesn't work very well to limit fraud.

Only if you get caught.
That's like saying "murder is proscribed only if you get caught".
Why do people buy that stuff? They could choose not to.
Well... we're generally used to "adulterants" referring to inactive or even potentially (purely) harmful ingredients being added to things to make them cheaper. However, note that "adulterating" your sexual potency supplement with Viagra means that it will, you know... work. Same with putting steroids in your workout supplement... it makes it work, better than the competition that doesn't do it.

There are all kinds of other problems with that, of course. I'm not saying it's a good idea. But in terms of "why would people buy these?", well, I'd suggest part of the reason is that people want to lose weight, be sexually potent, or get swole, and these "adulterated" supplements actually work. Just at a cost you may not have realized you were paying, or intended to pay.