Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by JoshuaAshton 2825 days ago
If you read into it, the new Code of Conduct actually may actually do more to ostracize people.

Notable contributors have already been harassed on Twitter and other platforms because apparently their actions outside of the Linux Kernel and LKML deem them breaking it, and people love to attack people for breaking rules.

There was also no-one really asking for a new Code of Conduct, and things weren't really broken. People are mostly just worried that its going to cause more issues and tension than when we had the lack of a proper CoC, or cause them to get targeted.

The Code of Conduct also has a few questionable statements, such as not judging people based on their technical abilities, which is a super important thing when you're actually developing one of the world's largest operating systems and people like to contribute garbage.

It was also, as the Author themselves has stated it was only made as a political statement, and the entire idea of it is to push an agenda. (^ See their twitter for where they said this)

Sometimes hostility and arguments really drive some people to do better at times also; and it makes people think about their code quality and double check it before they actually submit their patches -- you don't want to be slated by Linus if you submit rubbish do you?

2 comments

The Code of Conduct also has a few questionable statements, such as not judging people based on their technical abilities,

Have you actually read the CoC? Because I just did, and I couldn't find that line.

"In the interest of fostering an open and welcoming environment, we as contributors and maintainers pledge to making participation in our project and our community a harassment-free experience for everyone, regardless of [...] level of experience"
Don't harras the noobs is hardly the same as don't judge a contributor on the technical meritas of their work.
> The Code of Conduct also has a few questionable statements, such as not judging people based on their technical abilities, which is a super important thing when you're actually developing one of the world's largest operating systems and people like to contribute garbage.

Where exactly does the CoC state this?

"In the interest of fostering an open and welcoming environment, we as contributors and maintainers pledge to making participation in our project and our community a harassment-free experience for everyone, regardless of [...] level of experience"
You seem to be literally saying that harassment is necessary when developing operating systems. Is that your intention?