Totally fair, but then what use is the data? If we have totally different digestive reactions / problems, then can you really tell much of anything from the microbiome data?
> If we have totally different digestive reactions / problems, then can you really tell much of anything from the microbiome data?
Congratulations. You now understand why the folks trying to monetize microbiome are regarded as snake oil salesmen right now.
I'm sure there are broad strokes that are valid. You have a lot of bacterium X--that isn't good. You completely lack bacterium Y--that isn't good. Your overall diversity is low--you probably should try to correct that.
However, once you start getting into "you need specific bacterium X to solve specific problem Y", that's likely snake oil.
Biological systems are annoying like that. For any treatment X, there will be some, generally tiny, fraction of the population that responds to it.
The problem is finding a treatment that works in either 1) the vast majority of the population or 2) a readily identifiable minority of the population.
Microbiome work is probably going to produce some cool results, but it will take time to get there. Running experiments on people is time consuming and expensive.
Congratulations. You now understand why the folks trying to monetize microbiome are regarded as snake oil salesmen right now.
I'm sure there are broad strokes that are valid. You have a lot of bacterium X--that isn't good. You completely lack bacterium Y--that isn't good. Your overall diversity is low--you probably should try to correct that.
However, once you start getting into "you need specific bacterium X to solve specific problem Y", that's likely snake oil.
Biological systems are annoying like that. For any treatment X, there will be some, generally tiny, fraction of the population that responds to it.
The problem is finding a treatment that works in either 1) the vast majority of the population or 2) a readily identifiable minority of the population.
Microbiome work is probably going to produce some cool results, but it will take time to get there. Running experiments on people is time consuming and expensive.